6/01/2012

Review: 'For Greater Glory', starring Andy Garcia and Oscar Isaac


You know here in the United States not much is known about the history of our neighbor to the south, Mexico. For most the only parts we know are about the Alamo and that we got California from them. There is a lot of history down there and probably a lot of stories that can be told and should be told. That is what the film For Greater Glory is attempting to do here. For Greater Glory is a film starring a predominately Latin cast with many well known stars such as Andy Garcia and Eva Longoria. Now all these things sound great on paper but not so much on the screen.

For Greater Glory tells the story of the Cristero War in the mid to late 1920s in Mexico. The government put a ban on public religious practices and persecuted Roman Catholics throughout the country. Citizens who disagreed decided to rebel to oust the government in power and return the rights to practice religion back into the country. The film covers a lot of time of the conflict from the initial laws getting passed to the peaceful resistance to the escalation to an armed conflict.

See the sad thing about this movie is that whole story description sounds so interesting and worthy of some serious epic film making. Well that isn’t what we get. What we do get is something that is too long, at times overly melodramatic, manipulative of its audience and seriously wasting it’s acting talent on poor script. One thing that makes you think when watching this is that the whole thing is in English, the only Spanish spoken is the characters names. The movie also tries to follow way too many characters.  Andy Garcia is promoted as its star but really his character isn’t really followed any more than a few others. While onscreen Garcia is giving a great performance even though what he’s working with could be so much better. He’s at least making you want to watch the screen.

The direction by Dean Wright is just ok, nothing too bad or great. Some of the action set pieces are nice and gives an old school western vibe but feels like its shot on a sound stage somewhere instead of outside. The score is one of the main culprits of its manipulative tendencies; it has this need to play music that’s telling you to “be sad now” or “this is the rousing moments of inspiration”! It gets a little tired after awhile then totally expected.

One of the main problems with this movie is that the government is shown as cartoonishly evil. They do everything bad and terrorize everyone who dare question them. Like these guys are worst than the Empire inStar Wars. There is no thought are attempt to show that side of the conflict in any type of light other than the MOST EVIL EVER! Basically this whole thing felt like a compressed early 90s network TV Easter miniseries. Now if that is you type of the thing then more power to you but really you should sit this one out and enjoy the weather.